Film

Wants and Needs

A generational study on economic depressions

Status: Released

Wants and Needs, 60-second spot (1:00)

Why do recessions keep coming back? Six years of interviews and C-SPAN footage look for the answer in the generations who live through them.

Wants and Needs began before the last recession and kept filming through it. Over six years, Cap Averill II interviewed hundreds of people and worked through volumes of C-SPAN footage from Washington.

The film asks a plain question. Do the habits of each generation drive the cycle of boom and bust? History suggests they might.

It looks hard at the mistakes we keep repeating. Then it offers ideas for the generations still to come.

The 12 premises

  1. Premise 1

    Greed and selfishness cause depressions.

    The 1880s quote and the "greed, plain and simple" line argue that capitalists and laborers both overreach when everyone acts only in their own interest.

  2. Premise 2

    Depressions run on a generational cycle.

    They come about every 80 to 100 years, and wealth rarely survives three generations ("cobbler to cobbler in three generations").

  3. Premise 3

    Needs generations hand off to wants generations.

    Depression survivors focus on what they need. They then spoil their kids and shelter them from the hard lessons, and each generation after that takes the basics for granted.

  4. Premise 4

    The lessons get lost.

    The generation in power often stays quiet about the crash, and the teaching dies off with them. Two or three generations later, people say the regulations don't apply to them and deregulate. The savings and loan crisis (a 1980s wave of bank failures) is the example given.

  5. Premise 5

    Falling interest rates inflate bubbles.

    The teeter-totter model says that when rates go down, home and stock prices go up. Rates fell for about 30 years until they hit zero, so the Fed (the central bank) had nothing left to use when the crash came.

  6. Premise 6

    Bubbles feed themselves.

    People expect prices to keep rising, so they pile in. Rising stock and house values then convince them they don't need to save (the "fool's paradise").

  7. Premise 7

    Heavy borrowing and low saving set the stage.

    Easy credit, overconfidence, and buying things people don't need leave society fragile.

  8. Premise 8

    Safety nets encourage risky behavior.

    The Fed, deposit insurance, and expected bailouts work like a trapeze safety net. Banks take bigger risks when they think someone will catch them (economists call this moral hazard, meaning people take more risk when someone else covers the loss).

  9. Premise 9

    Fraud thrives in bubbles.

    When asset prices are soaring, promises of huge returns look believable. The Madoff scandal and the subprime mortgage mess (loans given to borrowers unlikely to repay) are the examples.

  10. Premise 10

    The usual warning signs are misleading or ignored.

    The Dow covers only 0.4% of public stocks, and Wall Street's way of counting gains hides the real losses. The inverted yield curve (long-term rates going above short-term rates, a classic recession signal) and the housing red flags were missed. Even the Fed said subprime wasn't a broad concern, while 88-year-old Donna Counts saw the crash coming.

  11. Premise 11

    Short-term thinking and rising debt get passed down.

    Politicians and Wall Street love lower rates for the quick boost. Lawmakers are afraid to ask for sacrifice, and deficits feed debt, which feeds deficits. The bill lands on Gen X, Y, and Z.

  12. Premise 12

    Regulation alone won't fix it. Education will.

    The public doesn't know the debt numbers, the Fed, or the Dow. The documentary argues we need to teach young people how interest rates and the economy work, so each generation doesn't have to relearn it the hard way.